Music Perception and the Dominance of Social Inhabitancies over Music Training School: Case of Western Music Performers Living in Iran

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Prof. in Dep. of Music, University of Arts

Abstract

Abstract
Analyzing the conventional music of different cultures using their own generated tools of music
theory is a preferred approach to illustrate the fundamental structure of music by insiders. Facts made
available through the mentioned approach explains the construction of music and the musical matters
in every culture which are not known through the conventional analytical systems, developed
and spread by western music theory. Such efforts have been done in examining the rhythmic principles
of Iranian music in some previous studies of authors. What occurs more in the current study
is using the music theory generated within the Iranian culture to examine the western viewpoint of
music performers living in such cultures to see how breathing in a different culture can influence the
fundamental musical perspective and the music perception, even if one plays a music coming from
thousands of miles outside that specific culture. In perusing this project a subject of 70 performers
participated. Among them 35 performers or the players of various western musical instruments wore
living in Iran (mostly natives) and the 35 persons were among players of Iranian traditional instruments,
and all of the them have participated voluntarily. The average professional background of the
performer was over 7 years. Three kinds of pieces played for both groups. The first one was purely
a piece of western music recorded and produced in West, entitled “Night is my sister” by Edna St.
Vincent Millay (Soprano by Wendy Lashbrook with 2’ 25” duration. The second piece was a Russian
one by Rimsky-Korsakov called “The Rose and the Nightingale” with 2’ 32” duration. The third one
was a piece of Purely Iranian traditional music by Aref-e-Ghazvini, recorded in Iran entitled Āmān,
with association of one of the masters of lyric / vocal Iranian traditional music, Mohammad Reza
Shajarian, and its duration was 4’ 26”. A questioner which was designed based on the fundamentals of
Iranian music theory handed to subjects to fill after listening to each piece. Some of the questions were
merely designed to examine the musical taste as well as the habit of subjects. There were questions
among them for testing if they think the pieces contain enough repetitions, ornamentations, rhythmic
complexities, distinguishable melodies, the compass, etc.; while the other ones examined the musical
ability and understanding of the subjects, such as asking about the strategy of composer to extend the
melodic range, boundaries of phrases, causes of rhythmic complexities, the nature of ornamentations,
lyrical-musical relationship and so forth. Results showed that the subjects of both groups shared views
in many significance issues in the two specific lines of investigations: musical tastes and the musical
judgments. The players of western music participated in this project have mostly been educated in
conservatories, in which the only kind of music that was taught has been the Western one, and The
methodology and principles of teaching were same as the methods taught in West. Therefore, it can
be concluded that the cultural inhabitancy influences on musical outlook of the person, more than the
musical schools do. In the other words, the common view points between the performers of Iranian
instruments and those of the Western, mostly based on the musical habits coming from the principles
imposed mostly by the culture, rather than anything else.

Keywords

References

منابع
- Azadehfar, Mohammad Reza (2006) Rhythmic Structure in Iranian Music, Tehran: Tehran
University of Art.
- Deschenes, Bruno (1998) “Toward and Anthropology of Music Listening”, International
Review of the Aesthetics and Sociology of Music, 29 (2):135-153.
- Eco, Umberto (1989) The Open Work, Translated by Cancogni , Anna, Cambridg, and Mass:
 
Harvard University Press.
- Fung, C. Victor (1992) “Musicians’ Preference and Perception for World Music” , Southeastern
Journal of Music Education, 4:178-190.
- Fung, C. Victor (1996) “Musicians’ and Nonmusicians’ Preferences for World Musics: Relation
to musical Characteristics and Familiarity”, journal of Research in Music Education, 44
(1): 60-83.
- Geisler, H.G. (1990) A Cross-Cultural Exploration of Musical Preference among Chinese
and Western Adolescents in Hong Kong, University of Michigan, Ph.D. Dissertation.
- Hicken, L.W. (1992) Relationship among Selected Listener Characteristics and Musical
Preference , Indiana University, Ph.D. Thesis.
- Holland, Dorothy and Naomi Quinn (1987) Cultural Models in Language & Thought Cambridge
, Cambridge University Press.
- Hopkins, Pandora (1982) “Aural Thinking”, In Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Music, edited
by Falck, Robert and Timothy Rice Toronto: University of Toronto Press: 143-161.
- Imberty, Michel (1993) “The Stylistic Perception of a Musical Work: An Experimental and
Anthropological Approach”, Contempotary Music Review, 7:33-48.
- Kessler, Annekatrin and Klaus Puhl, (2004), Subjectivity, Emotion, and Meaning in Music
Perception , Paper read at Conference on Interdisciplinary Musicology (CIM04), at Graz/Austria.
- Kippen, James (1988) “An Ethnomusicological Approach to the Analysis of Musical Cognition”
, Music Perception, 5:173-196.
- LeBlanc, A., (1987) “The Development of Music Preference in Children”, In Music and
child development, edited by C. Peery, I.W. Peery & T.W. Draper New York, Springer-Verlag:
137-157.
- Lee, Riley Kelly (1993) Yearning for the Bell: A Study of Transmission in the Shakuhachi
Honkyoku Tradition.
- Stock, Jonathan (1993) “The Application of Schenkerian Analysis to Ethnomusicology:
240- Problems and Possibilities” , Music Analysis, 12 (2): 215-

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics